Geometry Puzzles for a Winter’s Day

I am sorry to report that December has now fallen across the land.

It is December on the beaches. It is December in the streets. It is very specifically and intensely December outside my bedroom window, where 3-foot death icicles dangle, ready to fall and impale me as I step out into the frigid December of it all.

(Yes, we’re loving Minnesota, thanks for asking!)

Where can we find warmth in this frigid time? Yes, yes, the Southern hemisphere, but more usefully: in the life-giving geometry problems of Catriona Shearer, Puzzle Magician.

Here are three of her favorites from November. Come, friend; heat yourself by this fire.

 

#1: Sci-Fi Stained Glass

catriona 2019.11 a
A pattern of squares. All six colored areas are equal. What fraction is shaded?

Why do I dub this one “stained glass”? Because it has the delicate and symmetric beauty of a stained glass window, obviously.

But why “sci-fi”? That takes more explanation.

On Twitter, acclaimed sci-fi author Greg Egan chimed in with a crucial point: as stated, the problem is under-defined, allowing for an infinite family of solutions. Thus, Catriona added another condition: the whole diagram has bilateral symmetry.

To see why this is necessary, check out the nifty animation that Greg created. I, for one, am eager to watch the sci-fi film where all stained glass windows rotate like this.

 

#2: Kiddle’s Riddle

catriona 2019 11 b
The total blue area is equal to the purple area. What fraction of the trapezium is shaded?

(Note to my fellow U.S. readers: please forgive the Britishism “trapezium.” Actually, scratch that: don’t forgive it, embrace it! Trapezium is an adorable word.)

Catriona explained the genesis of this one:

Alison Kiddle, who coordinates my local MathsJam, asked me a question at last month’s meeting: could I draw a trapezium so that when I drew in the diagonals the four areas each had a different area? Could I draw one where 2 areas were equal, or 3, or all 4?

I was pretty confident that I could, but [spoiler] after a fair bit of scribbling and failing to convince Alison (who is very good at asking questions!) I realised I shouldn’t have been quite so hasty.

Naturally I’d brought my felt tips to the pub, so by the time I left I’d made this puzzle from my discoveries.

 

#3: The House of the Square Sun

catriona 2019 11 c
The yellow square has double the area of the red rectangle. How tall is the green rectangle?

I found this one the trickiest of the three. Indeed, Catriona says that these three are “in ascending order of difficulty (in my mind, at least).” She also¬†explains, tantalizingly:

Unless I missed it, I don’t think anyone posted the solution I originally came up with. It’s unusual for me to feel like my method is unique!

As always, feel free to post your solutions in the comments (which means you should watch out for spoilers if you don’t want them)!

6 thoughts on “Geometry Puzzles for a Winter’s Day

  1. All three seemed pretty easy to me, though I made the mistake on the first one of assuming that the squares in the center had the diagonals parallel to the sides of the main square (without that assumption or some similar one the problem does not have a unique solution). Making the area of the side squares 1, the red square has area 2, side length sqrt(2), which makes the middle side rectangles have diagonal sqrt(2), so they must be squares also, and the overall side length is 3, making 6/9 of the figure colored.

    For the second one, label the top a and the bottom b. The blue+purple triangle has area bh/2 so the purple triangle has 2/3 (bh/2) = bh/3. Each blue triangle has area bh/6. The height of the purple triangle is 2/3 h, so the height of the white one is 1/3 h, and the area of the white triangle is ah/6. But white+blue triangle has area ah/2 = ah/6+bh/6, so area of white triangle is half the area of the blue. That gives us proportions 1:2:4 for white:blue:purple areas, and 8/9 of the figure is shaded.

    The last one has a lot of red herrings. If we make x be the height of the red rectangle, then the red area is 12x, the square has area 24 x and the side of the square is sqrt(24 x). The right triangle within the red rectangle has two sides known, so the third side is sqrt(24x-x^2). The right triangle above the red rectangle is similar, so the vertical side is sqrt(24x-x^2) (sqrt(24x-x^2)/x) = 24-x. Thus the height of the green rectangle is 24. I got that answer for a couple of special cases first: the square parallel to the axes and the diagonals of the square parallel to the axes, so I’m pretty sure it is correct.

  2. Can non-mathematicians reply? I don’t quite see the puzzle in No. 1 (and the others are too hard for me). Is it assuming too much to start with the observation that one little square is 1/9 of the whole and that 6 times 1/9 equals 6/9 and that’s that?

Leave a Reply to Ben Orlin Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s